I liked it, which is all you need to know about that.
There are a series of excerpts from critical discussions and essays about the novel in the back of the book, and two minutes of thumbing through them reminded me of why I so very much loathe literary analysis and criticism: so much of it seems to be written solely for the critic to show off that he can toss off Biblical references, name drop Swift and Conrad, and manage to blow himself and use a thesaurus at the same time. I'm not saying all criticism is like this, but my God does a lot of it come across that way.
And also, another source of irritation. From the forward to the book, written by E. M. Forster:
"It is a pleasure and an honor to write an introduction to this remarkable book, but there is also a difficulty, for the reason that the book contains surprises, and its reader ought to encounter them for himself."
Forster then goes on, in the course of three pages, to give away not only the entire plot of the novel, but also reveals who lives and who dies, and reprints the entire last page of the book!
Now, I have more or less through cultural osmosis picked up on the plot points and such, but c'mon! I had a feeling this was coming when I read the first paragraph of the introduction, and so skipped over reading it until I'd finished the book, but really! If the reader "ought to encounter" the book's surprises on his own, don't you think you ought to shut the fuck up about what's going to be happening between the pages?
Do you want to know the secret of The Crying Game? Want to know what Rosebud was? Let me tell you what happened to Winston Smith at the end of 1984, save you the trouble of reading it.
And no, having it all spelled out for you beforehand doesn't mean that you will still enjoy the book in the same way. Narratives are meant to be experienced. I might read a book and enjoy the style of the author or admire his skill with dialogue and character development, but when I read something, generally I keep going because I want to know what's going to happen! Having everything revealed before the first page of the book is even read is sort of a bummer, you know?
I'll be sure to tear the forward out of the book before my daughter reads it. We don't want the thrill of discovery to be lost, do we?